Alex Burchmore
No. 122 - spring-summer 2019

Smashing Vases: Ceramics and the Aesthetics of Destruction in Works
by Ai Weiwei and Liu Jianhua


Ceramics are an ideal case study in the aesthetics of destruction. While a ceramic object can be preserved for centuries, it is always haunted by the chance that it might slip from unsteady hands or fall from an exposed shelf. The conceptual resonance of this fragility has long been esteemed in China—a nation so closely tied with ceramics that country and material are synonymous in the Anglophone imagination—and many Chinese artists have adopted ceramics to reveal the destruction inherent to contemporary society. Ai Weiwei and Liu Jianhua are among the most renowned proponents of this aesthetic. From the 1990s to the present, both have used ceramics to expose acts of violence that far exceed a simple smashing of vases, ranging from planned obsolescence, environmental degradation and ecological cycles of decay and renewal, to the redemptive power of destruction as a crucible for regeneration.

Ai Weiwei’s most iconic ode to destruction is his photographic triptych Dropping a Han Dynasty Urn (1995), usually read as a rejection of China’s past and its contemporary co-option by the state but legible also as a call to revitalise that heritage.1 Destruction is central to this renewal, liberating his appropriated ceramic from the weight of tradition and returning it to a lived existence. By removing the urn from the stasis of a museum case and dropping it to the floor, Ai restores its original identity as an unremarkable wine jar (hu 壶), “the dispensable material culture of [its] time … like mass-produced soda bottles are of


Want to read the rest of this article?
Subscribe to access our online content: choose option e-worm / hybrid / collector.
If you are already a subscriber, log in by clicking here >
Ai Weiwei, Dropping a Han Dynasty Urn, 1995. Gelatin silver photograph. Three sheets: 180 x 169.5 cm (each). Purchased 2006. The Queensland Government’s Gallery of Modern Art Acquisitions Fund. Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art. © Ai Weiwei.
Ai Weiwei, Dropping a Han Dynasty Urn, 1995. Gelatin silver photograph. Three sheets: 180 x 169.5 cm (each). Purchased 2006. The Queensland Government’s Gallery of Modern Art Acquisitions Fund. Collection: Queensland Art Gallery | Gallery of Modern Art. © Ai Weiwei.
Ai Weiwei, Dust to Dust, 2008. Powder from grinded Neolithic pottery (5000 – 3000 BC), glass, and wood, 200 x 240 x 36 cm. Photo: © Faurschou Foundation.
Ai Weiwei, Souvenir from Beijing, 2002. Photo: Courtesy of Ai Weiwei Studio.
Liu Jianhua, Dream, 2006. Sculpture Square, Singapore, Qingbai glazed porcelain, 3-channel DVD projection, 1200 x 900 x 80 cm. Photo: Courtesy of the artist.
Liu Jianhua, Discard, 2011. Sino-Italia Design Exchange Centre, Shanghai, installation of broken reproductions of historical porcelain vessels, variable dimensions. Photo: Courtesy of the artist.
Liu Jianhua, Discard, 2011. Sino-Italia Design Exchange Centre, Shanghai, installation of broken reproductions of historical porcelain vessels, variable dimensions. Photo: Courtesy of the artist.
Liu Jianhua, Discard (details), 2011. Sino-Italia Design Exchange Centre, Shanghai, installation of broken reproductions of historical porcelain vessels, variable dimensions. Photos: Courtesy of the artist.